Skip to content


In a captivating conversation between Gad Saad and Elon Musk last week, a profound topic surfaced, striking a chord with many: the dilemma of tribalism versus truth. This debate isn’t confined to just intellectual circles or casual discussions among friends; it’s a reflection of a broader, deeply ingrained human behavior that often pits group loyalty against the pursuit of objective truth. Despite the availability of overwhelming evidence that may contradict long-held beliefs, it seems that many are trapped within the confines of their worldview, unable to entertain the possibility that their perspective might be flawed.

The phenomenon of tribalism, as discussed by Saad and Musk, isn’t just a matter of political affiliation. It extends far beyond, affecting various spheres of life where individuals identify strongly with specific groups or ideologies. This allegiance to one’s “tribe” can sometimes overshadow an objective assessment of facts, leading to cognitive dissonance where contrary evidence is dismissed or rationalized away to protect the tribe’s prevailing narrative.

This stubborn adherence to tribal beliefs over empirical truth isn’t merely a social inconvenience; it’s a fundamental challenge to progress and understanding. The essence of human advancement lies in our ability to question, to doubt, and ultimately, to adapt our understanding based on new evidence. Yet, the allure of belonging and the comfort of conformity often eclipse this critical aspect of human nature.

Tribal leaders, or those who hold sway over collective opinion within these groups, wield significant influence. Their narratives shape the tribe’s perception of reality, often painting a picture that aligns with their interests or ideology. The danger here is not just in the misinformation or skewed perspective that might be propagated but in the suppression of individual critical thinking. When tribal loyalty demands unquestioning adherence, the tribe’s members are robbed of their capacity to engage with the world in a thoughtful, discerning manner.

The solution, however, is not to dismantle these social structures or to vilify the sense of community they provide. Instead, the call to action is for individuals within these groups to awaken their innate reasoning abilities—to dust off the cognitive tools that have been shelved in favor of tribal dogma. By re-engaging with our environment, questioning the narratives fed to us, and evaluating evidence with a critical eye, we can begin to bridge the chasm between tribal loyalty and an unwavering commitment to truth.

As we navigate the complexities of modern society, the emphasis should shift from tribalism to a broader, more inclusive identity: that of the human tribe. This isn’t a call to abandon our diverse identities and beliefs but to recognize the commonality in our quest for truth, understanding, and a better future. In embracing our collective humanity, we can foster a culture where differences are not just tolerated but celebrated, where dialogue and evidence take precedence over dogma.

The pursuit of truth, nuanced and elusive as it may be, remains a noble endeavor. It demands humility to accept that our understanding of the world is always evolving, courage to challenge deeply held beliefs, and a willingness to change our minds in the face of new evidence. In doing so, we not only honor the essence of our individuality but also contribute to a richer, more enlightened human tribe.



don't miss a single episode!


ai startups and the future

we don’t spam!

5 1 vote
Article Rating
Notify of

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x